Category Archives: Scott Maciver

Consistency in Worship by Scott Maciver

Scott Maciver has written a fine article over on the Our Confession website on the consistency of our holding to exclusive Psalmody:

“There are some today who have taken office in a church or are members of a church who would consider themselves to be exclusive psalmists and were we to ask them what their position on worship is; they would confidently assert that it would be that of exclusive psalmody. The test of the genuineness of our position comes when, like those referred to in Macrae’s Diary, we find ourselves in a worship setting out-with our own congregation or denomination where the worship is contrary to unaccompanied exclusive psalmody.

In such a situation, there are two options available to us. Do we continue to uphold the Biblical position we profess which forbids the worshiping of God in any other way not appointed in His Word (Westminster Shorter Catechism, Q51) or do we, when we are in a different setting, adopt a different position on worship all together? The temptation to some may be to partake in worship, no doubt offered in all sincerity, which is contrary to both that which we profess to believe and that which God has commanded in Scripture. Some may, for instance, sing the words of uninspired hymns to avoid giving offence to those sat in the pew next to them or to avoid disrupting the fellowship. Others may find themselves singing as they would consider it better to sing the words than to be silent and to not worship at all. Yet again, others may sing them as they consider the words to be theologically correct. On the other hand do we simply keep silent, not through any sense of superiority to those around us but by a consistent God honouring application of His commandments regarding worship?”

In answer to these questions, Maciver gives the following summary as an answer:

“Now that we have considered these two options open to us, we are left with a number of questions. Is our concern about obeying man before God when Scripture tells us that we ought to obey God rather than men (Acts 5:29)? Are God’s commandments only to be obeyed under certain circumstances and only in particular locations? Is our position on exclusive psalmody simply a preference or is it a conviction that we by God’s grace seek to consistently apply at all times? Finally, can it ever be defensible for an office-bearer who has vowed to exclusive psalmody to preside over public worship where uninspired hymns are being sung?”

These are great questions, I would be very interested in getting your feedback on these issues. For those who contribute to the forum at Our Confession, keep us updated on the discussion.